The Moral and Biblical insanity that is Christian Zionism
The rapturous applause of the U.S. Congress for the unctuous nonsense that poured from the mouth of the Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, in recent days pales into insignificance when compared to the out and out idolatrous behavior of philo-Zionists like John Hagee. Even the Israeli Knesset would not indulge their own Prime Minister in such a manner as the U.S. congress let alone the hysterical ravings of those Christians who wrap themselves in a Zionist flag and sing Hallelujah.
I believe that the Christian Church in the U.S., and the church in those countries who choose to follow their example, are facing the greatest danger of spiritual, moral and ethical collapse that has been seen in the Christian world for the last 500 years. This collapse into intellectual and theological bankruptcy is no doubt being lead by the Christian lobby that has replaced worship of its Savior with an allegiance to the state of Israel that would make David Ben Gurion blush. This insane devotion to the Zionist state forces Christians to abandon virtually every spiritual and ethical boundary for which they have been known for over the last 80 years. Like a co-dependent lover who can’t see that their relationship is destroying them, the Christian Zionists drown their own inner voices of conscience to the sound of praise for a secular state that opposes the preaching of the Gospel within its borders with greater vigor than Cuba or Venezuela ever have. The Zionist state forbids professing Christians to migrate to Israel. Similar behaviour by Arab states gets a firm rebuke by the religious right,citing this as evidence of the anti-Christ like nature of Islam as well as justification for supporting the state of Israel.
Advocates of the Christian right are almost universally supporters of anti-abortion doctrines. Laws allowing for abortion rights are deemed satanic and are frequently equated with Hitlers extermination of the Jews of Europe in the Holocaust. Yet Israel, seeing itself as a liberal democracy, made in the mold of civilised Europe, allows some 40,000 abortions every year. It is the only country in the region that has pro-abortion rights legislation yet once again the Christian Zionist movement has suddenly nothing to say about the matter.
Attempts to bring universal health care to the U.S. have found their most ardent opponents being members of the religious right. Universal health care is seen as just another step down the dark road to Socialism. Yet the Israeli system of universal health care is never held up as an example of Godlessness in action by right or left wing religious conservatives in the west.
The religious right is often very skeptical about the so called Christian confessions of their political leaders, particularly if they are black and Democrat. They hate to see religious belief being exploited by those whose real goal is the attainment of power, status and wealth without true belief in the God of the Bible. They want their Christian political leaders to be the “real deal”. Yet Israeli leaders can be out and out atheists who clearly use biblical texts to bolster their arguments while in truth seeing those biblical texts as being nothing more than myth and legend. Once again they do this without a word of criticism by the Christian Zionist masses.
Professor Amnon Raz-Krakotzkin of Ben-Gurion University is alleged to have once made the sarcastic comment, “Our claim to the land could be put in a nutshell: God does not exist, and He gave us this land.” Any such comment showing such open cynicism and exploitation of biblical belief by U.S. politicians would ensure their political doom.
Religious right doomsday prophets routinely predict the demise of the U.S. due to its abandonment of biblical ethics and values regardless of the fact that it was Moses and not George Washington who stood on Mount Sinai and accepted the covenant made with them by God regarding the land their people was to inhabit. No curses of destruction of the U.S. nation for abandoning the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob are revealed in the Old Testament. Yet the very nation whose destruction IS promised in scripture if they disobey the commandments of God, continue to reject both Torah values and the acceptance of Christ without a word of warning by Christian Zionists.
The Christian Zionist disdain for the U.N. continues regardless of the fact that it was the United Nations that created the state of Israel and that the U.N. Charter is deeply dependent on values obtained from the Christian and Jewish scriptures. U.S. Evangelicals that support Israel speak of a Jewish people “returning home” when in fact the Jews of Europe who went there during the Zionist migrations to Palestine would have not known Hebron from Albuquerque. The hundreds of thousands of Palestinians ( now numbering in the millions) who were forced to leave their actual brick and mortar residences in Palestine during the ethnic cleansing that took place in 1948, are considered to be illegitimate candidates for citizens of the land where they were born even though they still have the keys and the land title deeds to the houses they once occupied. Even if the Palestinians did leave of their own free will at the command of their Arab leaders (a point clearly refuted by the indisputable evidence from the archives of the Israeli Defense Force) the Israelis have no right to deny them return.
I have personally spoken to hundreds of Muslim followers regarding the Israel-Palestine issue and never once have I detected any hatred of Jewish people or animosity towards Christians. Yet the Christian Zionist world continually derides the Islamic faith and paints the picture that it is Muslims who are bred to hate Jews and detest all forms of the Christian faith. I am a Bible believing Christian and I have been invited to speak to Muslims on a number of occasions about the Israel-Palestine issue. I have always been able to talk about my own faith in Jesus without fear of being persecuted while at any of those meetings. It has been my experience that Muslim people have done everything to respect my faith. This obviously is not the case in all parts of the Islamic world but it is certainly true in many instances. It has NEVER been my experience for Christian Zionists to respect the beliefs of Muslims. No Muslim has ever told me that Jesus is damned, while I have heard Christian Zionists scream, at the tops of their voices, that the prophet Mohamed is in hell, in public places like Rundle Mall in the heart of Adelaide during rush hour. Whom is it that is being disrespectful of whom?
Muslims recognise that many Arabs in Palestine are Christian and even Hamas has allowed them to join them in government in Gaza. Yet these Christian brethren have been totally ignored by the religious right in the west. Their persecution by the Zionist state is not a topic for discussion. Stories of Christian persecution in the Middle East are never allowed to include the suffering of Palestinian Christians at the hands of the Zionist state.
If the Zionist state of Israel ever falls, then I believe the Jewish people will still flourish in the rest of the world (even in the Middle East). Christian Zionism, however, will be consigned to the already huge pile of kooky and dangerous ideas that Christians have managed to invent out of their distorted understanding of the Bible. Zionist Israel is more important to Christians Zionists than it is to the Jewish people themselves. The CZ’s are more Zionist than Israel. Their lack of tolerance for those different from themselves and for the oppressed of the world makes them less Christian than the truly Islamic.
It has been said that the attitude of the U.S. to Cuba is like the attitude of a werewolf to a full moon. It suffices to say that the Christian Zionist cult-like devotion to Israel does not permit them to be able to dispassionately debate the Israel-Palestine issue. I have discovered this, to my dismay, on too numerous instances to mention.
Craig Nielsen
ACTION FOR PALESTINE
25 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 28, 2011 at 6:42 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
I am Pro-Israel myself, and yeah an Anglican priest/presbyter. And yep I’m a Brit. (And one time Royal Marine, Gulf War 1, plus..) Sadly your arguments are ad hoc mostly. To each his own, however!
LikeLike
May 28, 2011 at 8:49 pm
Nuclear War in 2011 | countries that have nuclear weapons
[…] For more on this read: https://craignielsen.wordpress.com/2011/05/28/christian-zionism-more-zionist-than-israel-and-less-chr… Related to this you can read: […]
LikeLike
May 28, 2011 at 9:17 pm
Marti
Christian Zionists are no more Christian than the Egyptian pharaohs were. They are the liars and deceivers that Jesus Christ warned us about and they are the enemies of God. It is very hard for me to believe that the folllowers of John Hagee, and his disgusting ilk, are unaware that these Talmudic Jewish Zionists despise Jesus Christ and His true followers, since it`s out in the open for all to see. These “Christains’ are following the doctrines of demons, which obviously points to the spiritual condition of their ‘leaders’. As a true Holy Spirit baptized, born again Christian by the grace of God only, it is clear that this whole mess is as much spiritual, as it is physical. Never doubt in the existance of the spiritual realm because it is very real.
LikeLike
May 28, 2011 at 10:40 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
It is simply this kind of vitriolic that shows how really ignorant people are towards the reality of both Christian and Biblical Zionism. And again John Hagee simply does not represent every form and believe of Zionism. Just amazing hate and ad hominem!
LikeLike
May 28, 2011 at 10:45 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
And hopefully this link might present some objectivity?
http://christianactionforisrael.org/4thcongress2.html
LikeLike
May 28, 2011 at 10:47 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
*belief
LikeLike
May 30, 2011 at 1:27 pm
jeremy
This is a great blog!!
‘christian zionism’ is a disgrace to the reconciling heart of Christianity… It cares more about ‘nationalistic facades’ than the welfare of people!!
LikeLike
May 30, 2011 at 6:04 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
Another ad-hoc statement at best (really ad hom)! And those ‘nationalistic facades’, are in reality the defense and welfare of Israel itself, who are surrounded by enemies! And the only disgrace here is not to support our Jewish Brethren in their desire for democracy and freedom! If you know your Bible? One day Israel will be attacked and only a third survive, before Christ comes to deliver them! (Zech. 13:8-9 ; 14:1-4, etc.)
LikeLike
May 30, 2011 at 6:14 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
And btw, that’s just it.. few really know and believe the Bible! And here critical scholarship does not serve the Church (in the main), but only manifests unbelief!
LikeLike
June 12, 2011 at 5:41 am
Chuck
Well stated Jeremy. I don’t think any CZer deliberately discards the welfare of people, however, I do believe it is an unwitting byproduct of their by-covenant theology.
LikeLike
June 13, 2011 at 3:04 pm
jeremy
Yes, spot on Chuck! The ideology is so important that people’s welfare becomes very much secondary….So many christians who are also zionists don’t seem to ever think of the welfare of the many Palestinians – christian or not. When a Zionist/futurist view is all that matters, then the needs of real people can easily become lost and seen as not important.
LikeLike
June 3, 2011 at 10:28 am
Jimmy Lo
Great article Craig. Loved it 🙂
LikeLike
June 12, 2011 at 5:33 am
Chuck
Thought-provokingly refreshing, Craig. The ironies of CZ are legion. Personally, although I believe Hagee and company have been grossly misled by their own ill-fated paradigm, if they have trusted in the shed blood of Christ to redeem them from their iniquity, then I believe they are brothers in Christ. And I Am called to love them.
However, I believe the CZ views are not only unsupportable Biblically, but they appear to jettison almost the entire NT. I find it incredibly disingenuous for CZers to do everything in their power to move Jews back into Albuquerque, I mean Hebron, only to believe that they are sending two-thirds of them to a firey death in the battle of Armageddon. Not my idea of charity. Nothing like inviting them over for a pizza party, knowing that the serial killer hiding out next door has a weapons cache that he’s promised to use the next time you have a gathering.
Craig, I don’t believe in racism of any kind. I love the Jewish people and wish they’d all come to the knowledge of Jesus. But I live the Arabs and the Brits no less. The dividing wall of separation was forever torn down between Jew and Gentile. (Eph 2:14-15) Why must the Church continue the bigotry? And why don’t we support out Christian brothers in Palestine?
What do you know about Netanyahu? In the U.S., he would probably win if he were to run for president. He’s portrayed as a statesman and a hero. Any thoughts?
Thanks again. I’ll be reading the rest of your offerings. Bravo!
Blessings,
Chuck
LikeLike
June 12, 2011 at 5:48 am
craignielsen
Hi Chuck,
Yes I think Netanyahu is more popular in the U.S. than he is in Israel. It seems to me that he is just another typical right-wing Zionist. I doubt whether things in Palestine would be much different than they are today if someone else was in power.
Craig
LikeLike
June 12, 2011 at 7:02 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
Once again, we must look at the Holy Scripture…and also both “Biblical” and “Christian” Zionism! Something that this blog simply does not do!
http://christianactionforisrael.org/4thcongress2.html
LikeLike
June 13, 2011 at 12:54 pm
jeremy
Read Craig’s book Fr Robert for a full understanding of the issues…. also see Stephen Sizer’s ‘Christian Zionism. – http://stephensizer.blogspot.com/
LikeLike
June 13, 2011 at 3:00 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
Jeremy,
I have actually read some of Sizer. First, I lived in Israel in the late 90’s, and as I have noted I was a Royal Marine Commando, and officer for over ten years active service. So I speak somewhat too from my military experience and history. And none of us comes from some place of non bias or experience. But this is not just ideology for me. With that said, certainly we must see Israel as a secular Zionist nation, at least in the basic govermental whole, though of course there are religious Jews there somewhat also.
Indeed from the biblical and Christian standpoint Israel is not a Christian Nation, something we simply must remember. And also from the Biblical Christian Zionist position Israel is in its land in unbelief. Again, we simply cannot press the Nation of Israel on the level of so-called Christian ethics.
Finally, from a biblical and theological standpoint it is again simply unfair to throw around the idea of racism. This is also being done from the Gay community, and just what is the reallity of the Biblical ethic anyway? That again, is the issue the both OT and NT theology. And just how one draws their conclusions.
LikeLike
June 15, 2011 at 7:49 am
zaplation
Irishanglican you talk about unsupported, unbiblical explanations but you fail to give much yourself. You say “we simply cannot press the Nation of Israel on the level of so-called christian ethics”? I kind of agree but what system of ethics should we use? I would’ve thought the UN humanitarian rules would be a good start. I don’t think the bloggers here are anti-Israel – but more anti-apartheid-Israel. You can’t have a region who has one class of people so clearly up and above another group to the degree that those below (Palistianians in this case – Samaritans in Jesus’ time etc etc) have no voice for self-determination.
LikeLike
June 15, 2011 at 3:57 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
zaplation,
I did give a full link from the Christian Zionist Congress, 2001. Since this is a blog, and basicly just kinda opinions away, etc. One is not gonna change people’s minds or ideas really here either. Sadly most people don’t write on these things from personal experience, though I have shared a wee bit of mine. I try at least to hold to both personal conviction/experience and ideology/theology-faith.
Btw, the UN is simply a liberal political ideology. And the great question really is, just who are the Palistianians? For the most part, Arabs who quite simply hate Israel!
Here’s another link..
http://www.thejerusalemconnection.us/blog/2011/06/12/the-myth-of-zionist-racism.html
LikeLike
June 16, 2011 at 6:59 am
craignielsen
Your comments about Palestinians really shows a tremendous amount of ignorance. How much time have you spent living in the West Bank or Gaza? Your comments are the epitome of racist nonsense. Virtually every Palestine solidarity activist I know has either lived in or visited both Israel and the occupied territories. The anti-Zionist Jewish Rabbis, whose voice is suppressed by the Zionist State as much as possible, would completely disagree with everything you have said about Palestinians and Israel.
LikeLike
June 16, 2011 at 5:00 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
Craig,
As I have said, I served next to and trained with the Israeli Commando’s, myself a Royal Marine Commando, so no ignorance here at all. Just a real difference of both theology and ideology! And Israel has its liberals also…these so-called anti-Zionist Jewish Rabb’s.
Your own stuff and ideology is hardly conservative Judeo-Christian theology or Bible I might add. This is really the issue. i.e. true Biblical doctrine and theology, this simply must set our political feet too as real Bible Christians!
LikeLike
June 17, 2011 at 2:53 am
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
http://www.pre-trib.org/articles/view/does-jesus-fulfill-israels-land-promises
LikeLike
June 17, 2011 at 4:14 pm
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
Another link..
http://www.thejerusalemconnection.us/columns/2011/06/14/has-god-forsaken-his-people.html
LikeLike
June 16, 2011 at 12:00 am
zaplation
disagree with that huge generalisation about Palestinians. But even if your right didn’t Jesus say to love your enemies?
LikeLike
June 16, 2011 at 12:20 am
irishanglican ~ Fr. Robert
That verse applied generally, is also a “huge generalization”. Jesus hates some things also, like the doctrine of the Nicolaitan’s (a false priestly assumption?) God was never happy with this in the OT certainly! (Hosea 4, etc.)
LikeLike